Montana State-Idaho Showdown and Upsets Reshape Rankings

Week 5 of the FCS season delivered several compelling matchups between ranked opponents and significant upsets that have reshaped the championship picture. No. 3 Montana State solidified its position as a Big Sky frontrunner with a convincing 37-17 victory over No. 4 Idaho, while No. 2 North Dakota State continued its dominance with a 42-10 dismantling of No. 18 Illinois State in Missouri Valley Football Conference play. Meanwhile, Northern Arizona provided the weekend's most significant upset by defeating No. 10 Sacramento State 34-16, delivering a major blow to the Hornets' conference title aspirations.

The weekend featured several additional ranked matchups, with No. 7 Central Arkansas handling No. 25 Lamar 34-14, No. 5 South Dakota dominating No. 17 Southern Illinois 42-13, and No. 13 Mercer defeating No. 23 Wofford 22-3 to remain undefeated. The offensive explosion of the weekend came from No. 9 North Dakota, which scored an astonishing 72 points against Murray State in a 72-35 victory, while No. 8 Montana survived a shootout with Eastern Washington, prevailing 52-49 in a game featuring over 1,200 yards of total offense.

As conference play intensifies across the subdivision, several teams have solidified their positions as legitimate championship contenders. The top three teams - South Dakota State (on a bye), North Dakota State, and Montana State - maintained their rankings with impressive performances or rest weeks, while significant movement occurred throughout the middle and lower portions of the Top 25. With upsets and competitive games reshaping the landscape, Week 5 provided valuable insights into which programs have the potential to make deep playoff runs as the road to Frisco continues to unfold.

The Elite Tier: Championship Favorites

1. South Dakota State Jackrabbits (3-1) [Previous: 1]

South Dakota State maintained its hold on the top ranking during a bye week, providing the two-time defending national champions additional time to prepare for their Missouri Valley Football Conference opener. The Jackrabbits have solidified their position atop the FCS with three consecutive victories since their season-opening setback against FBS Iowa, outscoring opponents by a combined 108-10 margin during that stretch. Their balanced offensive attack and suffocating defense continue to establish them as the clear team to beat in 2024.

The Jackrabbits received 38 of 56 first-place votes in the latest Stats Perform FCS Top 25 Poll, confirming their status as the consensus championship favorite11. South Dakota State benefits from quarterback Mark Gronowski's experience and efficiency, having accounted for over 3,000 yards of total offense and 37 touchdowns during last season's championship run. Their defense has been equally impressive, allowing just 10 total points over their last three games.

South Dakota State returns to action in Week 6 with their MVFC opener at Northern Iowa, beginning a challenging conference schedule that will test their championship mettle. The Jackrabbits' championship pedigree and balanced excellence keep them firmly positioned at the top of the rankings, with their systematic approach creating a foundation for sustained success as they pursue an unprecedented third consecutive national title.

2. North Dakota State Bison (4-1) [Previous: 2]

North Dakota State delivered a statement performance with a dominant 42-10 victory over No. 18 Illinois State in their Missouri Valley Football Conference opener, establishing the Bison as clear championship contenders. Quarterback Cam Miller was nearly perfect, completing 20 of 23 passes for 216 yards and three touchdowns13 while orchestrating an offensive masterclass against one of the subdivision's typically solid defenses. The Bison controlled all three phases, building a substantial lead while never allowing the Redbirds to gain momentum.

Head coach Tim Polasek continues to maintain the championship standard established under his predecessors, with North Dakota State receiving 10 first-place votes in the latest Stats Perform FCS Top 25 Poll11. The Bison's balanced offensive approach, featuring Miller's efficient passing and a powerful rushing attack, creates consistent problems for opposing defenses. Their defensive front, among the FCS's most physically imposing units, limited Illinois State to minimal production throughout the conference opener.

North Dakota State enters Week 6 with significant momentum and a 1-0 record in MVFC play, preparing for an in-state rivalry showdown with North Dakota. The Bison's championship pedigree and balanced dominance keep them firmly positioned among the elite championship contenders, with their systematic approach creating a foundation for sustained success as they pursue their 10th national title since 2011. Their convincing victory over Illinois State serves as a reminder that North Dakota State remains one of the subdivision's premier programs.

3. Montana State Bobcats (5-0) [Previous: 3]

Montana State continued its perfect start to the season with a dominant 37-17 victory over Idaho State in their Big Sky Conference opener, further establishing the Bobcats as legitimate national title contenders. Running back Scottre Humphrey led the Bobcats with 159 rushing yards and 3 touchdowns as Montana State controlled all phases of the game. The victory improves them to 5-0 overall and 1-0 in Big Sky play, maintaining their position as one of the FCS's few remaining undefeated teams as they prepare for next week's crucial Big Sky showdown with Idaho.

Head coach Brent Vigen's program continues to demonstrate championship-level execution, receiving 7 first-place votes in the latest Stats Perform FCS Top 25 Poll despite maintaining their No. 3 ranking. The Bobcats' physical running game and efficient passing attack create consistent challenges for opposing defenses, while their defensive unit has limited opponents to just 20.2 points per game despite facing several high-powered offenses. Their perfect record through five games demonstrates their legitimacy as championship contenders.

Montana State enters Week 6 with significant momentum and confidence, preparing for a potential top-10 showdown with Idaho that could dramatically impact the Big Sky race. The Bobcats' balanced approach and championship pedigree make them formidable against any opponent, with their systematic approach creating a foundation for sustained success as they pursue their first national title since 1984. Their dominant start serves notice that Montana State must be considered among the elite championship contenders

4. South Dakota Coyotes (3-1) [Previous: 6]

South Dakota delivered a dominant performance with a convincing 42-13 victory over No. 17 Southern Illinois in their Missouri Valley Football Conference opener, establishing the Coyotes as legitimate championship contenders. Their rushing attack was particularly impressive, with Travis Theis and Charles Pierre Jr. combining for 271 yards and four touchdowns on the ground13, while quarterback Aidan Bouman added two explosive touchdown passes of 80 and 61 yards. The Coyotes controlled all three phases, improving to 3-1 overall and 1-0 in MVFC play.

Head coach Bob Nielson's program continues to demonstrate remarkable offensive balance, with their rushing attack averaging 6.9 yards per carry against the Salukis' typically stout defense. The Coyotes move up to No. 4 in the rankings following their impressive conference-opening victory, continuing their upward trajectory as one of the MVFC's premier teams. Their dominant showing against Southern Illinois provides significant momentum as they continue their conference schedule.

South Dakota enters Week 6 with increased championship aspirations, preparing for a road trip to Murray State as they look to maintain their perfect MVFC record. The Coyotes' balanced approach and improved execution make them formidable against any FCS opponent, with their systematic attack creating a foundation for potential success in the challenging MVFC. Their comprehensive victory over Southern Illinois serves notice that South Dakota must be considered among the elite championship contenders heading into the heart of conference play.

5. Villanova Wildcats (4-1) [Previous: 5]

Villanova maintained its position among the championship contenders with a workmanlike 24-10 victory over Long Island, controlling the tempo throughout while never allowing the Sharks to seriously threaten. The Wildcats bounced back from their loss to FBS Maryland the previous week, improving to 4-1 overall as they continue their pursuit of a Colonial Athletic Association championship. Though the performance lacked the explosiveness they've displayed in previous outings, Villanova's ability to control all three phases against LIU demonstrated their championship consistency.

Head coach Mark Ferrante's program continues to establish consistency on both sides of the ball, with their balanced offensive approach and opportunistic defense creating a foundation for sustained success. The Wildcats maintain their No. 5 ranking, with their lone defeat coming against FBS competition. Their perfect record against FCS opponents (4-0) reinforces their position among the championship contenders as they continue CAA play.

Villanova enters Week 6 with continued championship aspirations, preparing for a challenging conference matchup at Richmond. The Wildcats' balanced approach and championship pedigree make them formidable against any FCS opponent, with their systematic attack creating a foundation for potential success in the competitive CAA. Their ability to bounce back from the Maryland defeat with a convincing performance, even against lower-tier competition, demonstrates the mental toughness necessary for championship contention.

Championship Contenders

6. North Dakota Fighting Hawks (4-1) [Previous: 9]

North Dakota delivered a historic offensive explosion in a 72-35 victory over Murray State, setting a modern program record for points in a single game. The Fighting Hawks scored their highest point total since 1928, amassing 601 total yards while averaging a remarkable 10.0 yards per play13. Quarterback Simon Romfo was extraordinarily efficient, passing for 276 yards and four touchdowns on just nine completions - a staggering 30.7 yards per completion average - while running back Isaiah Smith added four rushing touchdowns in the offensive showcase.

Head coach Bubba Schweigert's program continues its upward trajectory following their upset of Montana earlier in the season, moving up to No. 6 following their impressive offensive display. The Fighting Hawks improve to 4-1 overall and maintain their position among the legitimate championship contenders. Their ability to generate explosive plays in bunches provides a dangerous dimension as they prepare for next week's rivalry matchup with North Dakota State.

North Dakota enters Week 6 with significant momentum and confidence, preparing for their most significant test of the season against in-state rival North Dakota State. The Fighting Hawks' balanced approach and explosive offense make them dangerous against any FCS opponent, with their systematic attack creating a foundation for potential success against the Bison. Their historic offensive performance against Murray State serves notice that North Dakota has evolved from playoff contender to legitimate championship threat.

7. Montana Grizzlies (4-1) [Previous: 8]

Montana survived a wild shootout with Eastern Washington, prevailing 52-49 in one of the season's most entertaining contests. The Grizzlies relied heavily on their potent rushing attack, which generated 349 yards and six touchdowns9 against the Eagles' porous defense. Quarterback Keali'i Ah Yat made FCS history by becoming the first Montana quarterback to rush for four touchdowns in a single game, showcasing his dual-threat capabilities in the high-scoring affair that featured over 1,200 yards of total offense.

Head coach Bobby Hauck's program continues to demonstrate remarkable offensive firepower, with their big-play capability creating consistent challenges for opposing defenses. The Grizzlies move up to No. 7 in the rankings following their fifth consecutive victory, further establishing themselves as legitimate Big Sky contenders despite their early-season inconsistency. Their thrilling victory over Eastern Washington provides additional momentum as they continue conference play.

Montana enters Week 6 with significant confidence in their offensive capabilities, preparing for another challenging Big Sky contest against Northern Colorado. The Grizzlies' explosive offense and improving defense make them dangerous against any FCS opponent, with their systematic attack creating a foundation for potential success in the competitive Big Sky. Their ability to prevail in a shootout demonstrates their offensive ceiling, though defensive concerns remain heading into the heart of conference play.

8. Central Arkansas Bears (4-1) [Previous: 7]

Central Arkansas continued its impressive start to the season with a convincing 34-14 victory over No. 25 Lamar, further establishing the Bears as United Athletic Conference favorites. The Bears controlled the tempo throughout, building a substantial lead while never allowing the Cardinals to seriously threaten. The victory improves them to 4-1 overall and 2-0 in UAC play, maintaining their position among the championship contenders as they continue their conference schedule with significant momentum.

Head coach Nathan Brown's program continues to demonstrate remarkable balance on both sides of the ball, with their efficient offense generating 34 points against Lamar's typically solid defense. The Bears drop one spot to No. 8 despite their impressive victory due to North Dakota's historic offensive explosion. Their dominant performance against Lamar provides additional confidence as they navigate the challenging UAC schedule ahead.

Central Arkansas enters Week 6 with continued championship aspirations, preparing for another conference matchup against Abilene Christian. The Bears' balanced approach and improved execution make them formidable against any FCS opponent, with their systematic attack creating a foundation for potential success in the competitive UAC. Their victory over a ranked conference opponent serves notice that Central Arkansas must be considered the clear UAC favorite and a legitimate championship contender.

9. UC Davis Aggies (4-1) [Previous: 14]

UC Davis delivered the weekend's most significant upset with a 28-26 victory over No. 4 Idaho, establishing the Aggies as legitimate Big Sky contenders and potential championship threats. After falling behind 14-0 in the first quarter, UC Davis outscored the Vandals 28-3 until the fourth quarter, then withstood a furious comeback attempt to secure the program's first victory over a top-five opponent in their FCS history5. Quarterback Miles Hastings orchestrated a masterful performance, completing 25-of-32 passes for 248 yards and three touchdowns against Idaho's typically stout defense.

Head coach Tim Plough's program continues to demonstrate remarkable resilience, with their defense forcing three critical turnovers inside their own territory despite allowing over 450 total yards to Idaho's balanced attack5. The Aggies surge to No. 9 in the rankings following their signature victory, continuing their upward trajectory as one of the Big Sky's most dangerous teams. Their ability to overcome an early deficit against a top-five opponent demonstrates their championship potential.

UC Davis enters Week 6 with significantly enhanced championship aspirations, preparing for another challenging Big Sky contest against Portland State. The Aggies' balanced approach and improved execution make them dangerous against any FCS opponent, with their systematic attack creating a foundation for potential success in the competitive Big Sky. Their upset victory over Idaho serves notice that UC Davis must be considered among the legitimate championship contenders.

10. Idaho Vandals (3-2) [Previous: 4]

Idaho suffered a disappointing 28-26 defeat to No. 14 UC Davis, falling from the ranks of the championship favorites while still maintaining their position among the contenders. The Vandals started strong with a 14-0 first-quarter lead but struggled through the middle portions of the game, getting outscored 28-3 until mounting a furious fourth-quarter comeback that fell just short5. The setback drops them to 3-2 overall and 1-1 in Big Sky play, creating significant questions about their championship ceiling despite their impressive early-season resume that includes victories over Wyoming (FBS) and UAlbany.

Head coach Jason Eck's program demonstrated championship resilience in their comeback attempt, though their inability to protect the football proved costly, with three turnovers inside UC Davis territory hampering their offensive production5. The Vandals drop to No. 10 in the rankings following their conference defeat, creating additional pressure heading into next week's showdown with undefeated Montana State. Their ability to bounce back from this setback will define their championship aspirations moving forward.

Idaho enters Week 6 facing a pivotal matchup against No. 3 Montana State that could potentially eliminate them from Big Sky title contention with a loss. The Vandals' balanced approach and improved talent level still make them dangerous against any FCS opponent, with their systematic attack creating a foundation for potential success if they can address their turnover issues. Their proven ability to compete with (and defeat) quality competition keeps them positioned among the championship contenders despite this disappointing defeat.

Playoff Contenders

11. Mercer Bears (5-0) [Previous: 13]

Mercer continued its perfect start to the season with an impressive 22-3 victory over No. 23 Wofford, establishing the Bears as legitimate Southern Conference favorites and maintaining their unblemished record. The Bears dominated defensively, holding Wofford to just 146 total yards and 2.6 yards per play while forcing four interceptions5. The victory improves them to 5-0 overall and 2-0 in SoCon play, marking the first time in program history that Mercer has started a season with five consecutive victories5.

Head coach Keith Hatcher's program continues to rely on what might be the FCS's most dominant defense, allowing just 3 points against a ranked conference opponent one week after holding The Citadel to 3 points. The Bears move up to No. 11 in the rankings following their second victory over a ranked SoCon opponent, having previously defeated Chattanooga. Their ability to consistently shut down opposing offenses while generating enough points for victory demonstrates their championship potential.

Mercer enters Week 6 with enhanced championship aspirations, preparing for another conference matchup against Furman as they look to maintain their perfect record. The Bears' defensive dominance and improved offensive execution make them dangerous against any FCS opponent, with their systematic approach creating a foundation for potential success in the competitive SoCon. Their victory over Wofford serves notice that Mercer must be considered the clear SoCon favorite and a legitimate playoff contender with championship upside.

12. William & Mary Tribe (4-1) [Previous: 11]

William & Mary delivered one of the weekend's most dominant performances with a convincing 49-7 victory over Hampton, establishing the Tribe as legitimate Colonial Athletic Association contenders. William & Mary controlled all phases of the game, building a substantial lead behind their balanced offensive attack and suffocating defense. The victory improves them to 4-1 overall and 2-0 in CAA play, maintaining their position among the playoff contenders as they continue their conference schedule with significant momentum.

Head coach Mike London's program continues to demonstrate remarkable balance on both sides of the ball, with their efficient offense generating seven touchdowns against Hampton's overmatched defense. The Tribe move up to No. 12 in the rankings following their impressive performance, continuing their upward trajectory as one of the CAA's most dangerous teams. Their dominant showing against Hampton provides additional confidence as they navigate the challenging conference schedule ahead.

William & Mary enters Week 6 with enhanced championship aspirations, preparing for another conference matchup against Stony Brook as they look to maintain their perfect CAA record. The Tribe's balanced approach and improved execution make them dangerous against any FCS opponent, with their systematic attack creating a foundation for potential success in the competitive CAA. Their dominant victory over Hampton serves notice that William & Mary must be considered among the legitimate contenders for the conference championship and an FCS playoff berth.

13. Southeast Missouri Redhawks (4-1) [Previous: 14]

Southeast Missouri State continued its impressive start to the season with a defensive masterpiece in a 19-0 shutout of Northwestern State, further establishing the Redhawks as Big South-OVC favorites. SEMO controlled the tempo throughout, with their defense recording their first shutout of the season while their offense generated just enough production for a comfortable victory. The win improves them to 4-1 overall and 2-0 in conference play, maintaining their position among the playoff contenders as they continue their conference schedule with significant momentum.

Head coach Tom Matukewicz's program continues to demonstrate remarkable balance on both sides of the ball, with their defense holding Northwestern State to minimal production throughout the contest. The Redhawks move up to No. 13 in the rankings following their fourth consecutive victory, continuing their upward trajectory as one of the Big South-OVC's most dangerous teams. Their shutout victory provides additional confidence as they navigate the challenging conference schedule ahead.

Southeast Missouri State enters Week 6 with enhanced playoff aspirations, preparing for another conference matchup as they look to maintain their perfect conference record. The Redhawks' balanced approach and improved execution make them dangerous against any FCS opponent, with their systematic attack creating a foundation for potential success in the Big South-OVC. Their shutout victory serves notice that SEMO must be considered the clear conference favorite and a legitimate playoff contender with championship upside.

14. Tarleton State Texans (4-1) [Previous: 16]

Tarleton State secured a thrilling 36-33 victory over Southeastern Louisiana, continuing the Texans' impressive start to the season and further establishing them as United Athletic Conference contenders. Tarleton State demonstrated remarkable resilience throughout the back-and-forth contest, making crucial plays in key moments to overcome a determined Lions squad. The victory improves them to 4-1 overall and 2-0 in UAC play, maintaining their position among the playoff contenders as they continue their conference schedule with significant momentum.

Head coach Todd Whitten's program continues to demonstrate remarkable offensive firepower, with their balanced attack generating 36 points against Southeastern Louisiana's typically solid defense. The Texans move up to No. 14 in the rankings following their fourth consecutive victory, continuing their upward trajectory as one of the UAC's most dangerous teams. Their hard-fought victory provides additional confidence as they navigate the challenging conference schedule ahead.

Tarleton State enters Week 6 with enhanced playoff aspirations, preparing for another conference matchup as they look to maintain their perfect UAC record. The Texans' balanced approach and improved execution make them dangerous against any FCS opponent, with their systematic attack creating a foundation for potential success in the competitive UAC. Their victory over Southeastern Louisiana serves notice that Tarleton State must be considered among the legitimate contenders for the conference championship and an FCS playoff berth.

15. Illinois State Redbirds (3-2) [Previous: 18]

Illinois State suffered a disappointing 42-10 defeat to No. 2 North Dakota State, raising questions about the Redbirds' ceiling while not significantly diminishing their playoff aspirations. Illinois State struggled to establish offensive consistency against the Bison's elite defense, generating limited production while surrendering explosive plays to NDSU's balanced attack. The setback drops them to 3-2 overall and 0-1 in Missouri Valley Football Conference play, creating additional pressure heading into next week's conference matchup.

Head coach Brock Spack's program struggled against championship-caliber competition, though the quality of the opponent mitigates concerns about their overall potential. The Redbirds drop to No. 15 in the rankings following their conference-opening defeat, though they remain positioned among the playoff contenders due to their quality victories in non-conference play. Their ability to bounce back from this setback will define their playoff aspirations moving forward.

Illinois State enters Week 6 facing an important conference matchup as they look to rebound from their decisive defeat. The Redbirds' balanced approach and talented roster still make them dangerous against most FCS opponents, with their systematic attack creating a foundation for potential success if they can address the issues exposed by North Dakota State. Their proven ability to compete with quality competition keeps them positioned among the playoff contenders despite this disappointing defeat.

16. Abilene Christian Wildcats (3-2) [Previous: 20]

Abilene Christian delivered an offensive explosion in a 55-30 victory over Utah Tech, continuing the Wildcats' impressive start to the season and further establishing them as United Athletic Conference contenders. ACU controlled the tempo throughout, with their balanced offensive attack generating explosive plays in bunches against Utah Tech's overmatched defense. The victory improves them to 3-2 overall and 1-1 in UAC play, maintaining their position among the playoff contenders as they continue their conference schedule.

Head coach Keith Patterson's program continues to demonstrate remarkable offensive firepower, with their balanced attack generating 55 points and over 500 total yards against Utah Tech. The Wildcats move up to No. 16 in the rankings following their convincing victory, continuing their upward trajectory as one of the UAC's most dangerous teams. Their offensive explosion provides additional confidence as they prepare for a challenging matchup with Central Arkansas next week.

Abilene Christian enters Week 6 with enhanced playoff aspirations, preparing for a pivotal UAC showdown against No. 8 Central Arkansas that could dramatically impact the conference race. The Wildcats' explosive offense and improving defense make them dangerous against any FCS opponent, with their systematic attack creating a foundation for potential success in the competitive UAC. Their victory over Utah Tech serves notice that Abilene Christian must be considered among the legitimate contenders for the conference championship and an FCS playoff berth.

17. Southern Illinois Salukis (2-3) [Previous: 15]

Southern Illinois suffered a disappointing 42-13 defeat to No. 5 South Dakota, raising significant questions about the Salukis' ceiling while not completely diminishing their playoff aspirations. SIU struggled to establish offensive consistency against the Coyotes' stingy defense, generating limited production while surrendering explosive plays to South Dakota's balanced attack. The setback drops them to 2-3 overall and 0-1 in Missouri Valley Football Conference play, creating additional pressure heading into next week's conference matchup.

Head coach Nick Hill's program struggled against championship-caliber competition, though the quality of the opponent mitigates concerns about their overall potential. The Salukis drop to No. 17 in the rankings following their conference-opening defeat, though they remain positioned among the playoff contenders due to their victory over Incarnate Word in non-conference play. Their ability to bounce back from this setback will define their playoff aspirations moving forward.

Southern Illinois enters Week 6 facing an important conference matchup as they look to rebound from their decisive defeat. The Salukis' offensive potential and talented roster still make them dangerous against most FCS opponents, with their systematic attack creating a foundation for potential success if they can address the issues exposed by South Dakota. Their proven ability to compete with quality competition keeps them positioned among the playoff contenders despite this disappointing defeat.

18. Northern Arizona Lumberjacks (3-2) [New]

Northern Arizona delivered the weekend's most significant upset with a convincing 34-16 victory over No. 10 Sacramento State, establishing the Lumberjacks as legitimate Big Sky dark horses. NAU controlled the tempo throughout, building a substantial lead while never allowing the Hornets to seriously threaten. The victory improves them to 3-2 overall and 1-0 in Big Sky play, vaulting them into the rankings for the first time since September 201811 and positioning them among the playoff contenders as they continue their conference schedule with significant momentum.

Head coach Chris Ball's program demonstrated remarkable balance on both sides of the ball, with their efficient offense generating 34 points against Sacramento State's typically stout defense. The Lumberjacks enter the rankings at No. 18 following their stunning upset, emerging as one of the Big Sky's most dangerous teams. Their dominant performance against Sacramento State provides significant confidence as they navigate the challenging conference schedule ahead.

Northern Arizona enters Week 6 with newfound playoff aspirations, preparing for another conference matchup as they look to build on their perfect Big Sky start. The Lumberjacks' balanced approach and improved execution make them dangerous against any FCS opponent, with their systematic attack creating a foundation for potential success in the competitive Big Sky. Their upset victory serves notice that Northern Arizona must be considered a legitimate playoff contender heading into the heart of conference play.

Final Top 25 Spots

19. Sacramento State Hornets (2-3) [Previous: 10]

Sacramento State suffered a stunning 34-16 defeat to Northern Arizona, raising significant questions about the Hornets' championship aspirations. Sacramento State struggled to establish offensive consistency against the Lumberjacks, generating limited production while surrendering explosive plays to NAU's balanced attack. The setback drops them to 2-3 overall and 1-1 in Big Sky play, creating additional pressure heading into next week's conference matchup.

Head coach Andy Thompson's program struggled against an unranked opponent, a concerning development for a team that has dominated the Big Sky in recent seasons. The Hornets drop nine spots to No. 19 in the rankings following their surprising defeat, though they remain positioned among the playoff contenders due to their championship pedigree and victory over Portland State in conference play. Their ability to bounce back from this setback will define their playoff aspirations moving forward.

Sacramento State enters Week 6 facing an important conference matchup as they look to rebound from their decisive defeat. The Hornets' balanced approach and talented roster still make them dangerous against most FCS opponents, with their systematic attack creating a foundation for potential success if they can address the issues exposed by Northern Arizona. Their championship pedigree from three consecutive Big Sky titles (2021-2023) keeps them positioned among the playoff contenders despite this disappointing defeat.

20. McNeese Cowboys (4-2) [New]

McNeese delivered a statement performance with a thrilling 28-26 upset victory over No. 25 Weber State, establishing the Cowboys as legitimate Southland Conference contenders and completing an extraordinary turnaround under second-year head coach Gary Goff. One season after going winless, McNeese has won four of its first six games, including a quality road victory over a traditionally strong Weber State program. The Cowboys enter the rankings for the first time since February 202111, positioned among the playoff contenders as they prepare for conference play.

Head coach Gary Goff has orchestrated one of the FCS's most remarkable turnarounds, with the Cowboys building on their early-season near-upset of Tarleton State with consecutive victories. McNeese enters the rankings at No. 20 following their breakthrough upset, emerging as one of the Southland Conference's most dangerous teams. Their victory over Weber State provides significant confidence as they prepare for their conference schedule.

McNeese enters Week 6 with legitimate playoff aspirations, preparing for their Southland Conference opener against Northwestern State. The Cowboys' balanced approach and improved execution make them dangerous against any FCS opponent, with their systematic attack creating a foundation for potential success in the competitive Southland. Their upset victory serves notice that McNeese must be considered a legitimate playoff contender heading into conference play, completing their transformation from winless to ranked in just one season.

21. UAlbany Great Danes (1-3) [Previous: 21]

UAlbany suffered a disappointing 34-20 defeat to Maine, raising significant questions about the Great Danes' championship aspirations following their semifinal appearance last season. UAlbany struggled to establish offensive consistency against the Black Bears, generating limited production while surrendering explosive plays to Maine's balanced attack. The setback drops them to 1-3 overall and 0-1 in Colonial Athletic Association play, creating additional pressure heading into next week's conference matchup.

Head coach Greg Gattuso's program has struggled to replicate last season's success following significant personnel losses to graduation and the transfer portal. The Great Danes remain at No. 21 in the rankings despite their third defeat in four games, though their position has become increasingly tenuous. Their ability to bounce back from this setback will define their playoff aspirations moving forward, with their championship pedigree from last season's semifinal run providing the benefit of the doubt in the rankings.

UAlbany enters Week 6 facing a must-win conference matchup as they look to rebound from their disappointing defeat. The Great Danes' balanced approach and coaching expertise still make them dangerous against most FCS opponents, with their systematic attack creating a foundation for potential success if they can address the issues exposed by Maine. Their championship pedigree from last season keeps them positioned among the playoff contenders despite their disappointing start, though their margin for error has been essentially eliminated.

22. ETSU Buccaneers (3-2) [New]

ETSU delivered an inspiring 34-17 victory over The Citadel in extraordinarily challenging circumstances, with the program and surrounding community dealing with the devastating impact of Hurricane Helene. Despite significant infrastructure damage in the region and the emotional toll of the natural disaster, the Buccaneers demonstrated remarkable resilience in controlling the contest from start to finish. The victory improves them to 3-2 overall and 1-1 in Southern Conference play, vaulting them into the rankings and positioning them among the playoff contenders.

Head coach George Quarles' program has shown extraordinary character throughout the early portion of the season, including a competitive performance against North Dakota State that saw the Buccaneers lead the Bison by 12 points with two minutes remaining. ETSU enters the rankings at No. 22 following consecutive victories over Elon and The Citadel, emerging as one of the Southern Conference's most dangerous teams. Their victory amid natural disaster conditions provides significant confidence as they continue their conference schedule.

ETSU enters Week 6 with legitimate playoff aspirations, preparing for another SoCon matchup as they look to build on their emotional victory. The Buccaneers' balanced approach and improved execution make them dangerous against any FCS opponent, with their systematic attack creating a foundation for potential success in the competitive Southern Conference. Their victory over The Citadel, combined with their near-upset of North Dakota State, serves notice that ETSU must be considered a legitimate playoff contender heading into the heart of conference play.

23. New Hampshire Wildcats (3-1) [Previous: 24]

New Hampshire maintained its position in the rankings during a bye week, providing the Wildcats an opportunity to prepare for the challenging Colonial Athletic Association schedule ahead. Following victories over Holy Cross, Central Connecticut State, and Towson, New Hampshire's week off allowed head coach Rick Santos to address any concerns from their first four performances while focusing on their upcoming conference challenges. Despite their inactivity, the Wildcats move up one spot to No. 23 in the rankings.

New Hampshire has established itself as a legitimate CAA contender through the first third of the season, with their balanced offensive approach and opportunistic defense creating a foundation for sustained success. The Wildcats' perfect record against FCS competition (their lone loss came to FBS Central Michigan) positions them favorably as they prepare for the heart of their conference schedule, with their systematic attack creating a foundation for potential success in the competitive CAA.

New Hampshire enters Week 6 with legitimate playoff aspirations, preparing for a challenging conference matchup against Delaware. The Wildcats' balanced approach and improved execution make them dangerous against any FCS opponent, with their systematic attack creating a foundation for potential success in the competitive CAA. Their early-season consistency serves notice that New Hampshire must be considered among the legitimate contenders for the conference championship and an FCS playoff berth.

24. Rhode Island Rams (3-1) [Previous: 22]

Rhode Island maintained its position in the rankings during a bye week, providing the Rams an opportunity to prepare for the challenging Colonial Athletic Association schedule ahead. Following victories over Bryant, Delaware State, and Long Island, Rhode Island's week off allowed head coach Jim Fleming to address any concerns from their first four performances while focusing on their upcoming conference challenges. Despite their inactivity, the Rams drop two spots to No. 24 in the rankings due to the entrance of new teams.

Rhode Island has established itself as a legitimate CAA contender through the first third of the season, with their balanced offensive approach and opportunistic defense creating a foundation for sustained success. The Rams' perfect record against FCS competition (their lone loss came to FBS UMass) positions them favorably as they prepare for the heart of their conference schedule, with their systematic attack creating a foundation for potential success in the competitive CAA.

Rhode Island enters Week 6 with legitimate playoff aspirations, preparing for a challenging conference matchup against Elon. The Rams' balanced approach and improved execution make them dangerous against any FCS opponent, with their systematic attack creating a foundation for potential success in the competitive CAA. Their early-season consistency serves notice that Rhode Island must be considered among the legitimate contenders for the conference championship and an FCS playoff berth.

25. Stony Brook Seawolves (4-1) [New]

Stony Brook continued its surprising season with a convincing 22-3 victory over Morgan State, establishing the Seawolves as legitimate Colonial Athletic Association dark horses. Stony Brook controlled the tempo throughout, with their defense allowing just three points while their offense generated consistent production. The victory improves them to 4-1 overall, vaulting them into the rankings for the first time this season and positioning them among the playoff contenders as they continue their CAA schedule.

Head coach Chuck Priore's program has been one of the FCS's most pleasant surprises, with the Seawolves building momentum with each victory. Stony Brook enters the rankings at No. 25 following their fourth win in five games, emerging as one of the CAA's most dangerous teams. Their dominant defensive performance against Morgan State provides significant confidence as they prepare for conference play, with their lone defeat coming against FBS Temple in the season opener.

Stony Brook enters Week 6 with newfound playoff aspirations, preparing for a challenging CAA matchup against William & Mary that will provide a significant test of their legitimacy. The Seawolves' defensive excellence and improved offensive execution make them dangerous against any FCS opponent, with their systematic approach creating a foundation for potential success in the competitive CAA. Their impressive start serves notice that Stony Brook must be considered a legitimate playoff contender heading into conference play.

Conclusion

Week 5 of the FCS season delivered a compelling combination of dominant performances from top-ranked teams and significant upsets that have further clarified the championship picture. No. 3 Montana State continued its perfect start with a convincing victory over Idaho State, while No. 2 North Dakota State demonstrated its championship pedigree with a dominant performance against Illinois State. Meanwhile, Northern Arizona provided the weekend's most significant surprise by upsetting No. 10 Sacramento State, while No. 14 UC Davis secured a statement victory over No. 4 Idaho.

As conference play intensifies across the subdivision, several teams have solidified their positions as legitimate championship contenders. The elite tier remains largely unchanged, with South Dakota State maintaining its top ranking during a bye week, while North Dakota State and Montana State continue to demonstrate why they're considered prime championship threats. The most significant movement came in the middle of the rankings, with UC Davis surging after its upset victory over Idaho, while Sacramento State tumbled following its surprising defeat to Northern Arizona.

Looking ahead to Week 6, several compelling matchups promise to further reshape the championship landscape. The weekend's premier showdown features No. 3 Montana State hosting No. 10 Idaho in a game with significant Big Sky implications, while No. 6 North Dakota visits No. 2 North Dakota State in an in-state rivalry with national championship implications. With the road to Frisco becoming increasingly defined through these early-season results, Week 5 represented another significant step toward determining which programs have legitimate championship aspirations in 2024.